7 Best Places to Sell Tiffany Jewelry [2024]

by Ryan Hart | Updated on March 28, 2024 | Post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

If you want to sell your special Tiffany jewelry online, it can be hard to know who to trust. Lots of people might want to buy it, but who will give you the most money?

That’s why we made a list of the best places to sell your Tiffany jewelry. These companies will give you fair offers, and make it easy to sell.

Keep reading to find the best buyer for your Tiffany jewelry.

Woman wearing rings


Where to sell Tiffany jewelry?


Here is a list of our favorite jewelry buyers that accept Tiffany jewelry:


1. Worthy



Worthy has a team of experts who know everything there is to know about Tiffany jewelry. They’ll take care of each step of the selling process, from evaluating your piece to finding the perfect buyer for it.

Plus, selling with Worthy is super easy and convenient. All you have to do is fill out a quick form on their website and send in your item (they even provide free shipping!).

Then, they’ll take care of everything else - including taking professional photos and writing up a detailed description.

But here’s what sets Worthy apart: they use an auction system, meaning multiple buyers will bid on your item. This ensures that you get the highest possible price for your jewelry.

And don’t worry if you aren’t happy with any of the bids - if you decide not to sell at any point during the process, Worthy will return your item free of charge.

Sell with Worthy


2. TheRealReal



TheRealReal is a trusted website that specializes in luxury consignment. They have a team of experts who authenticate each item sold on their site, so buyers can be sure they are getting the real deal.

When it comes specifically to selling Tiffany jewelry, TheRealReal has an extensive knowledge of the brand’s history and designs. This means they can accurately price your items and provide detailed descriptions to attract buyers who appreciate high-quality jewelry.

Another great thing about using TheRealReal is their white-glove service. This means that they handle everything from taking professional photos of your items to shipping them out once they are sold. You don’t need to worry about anything!

Lastly, selling on The Real Real gives you access to a huge community of luxury shoppers from around the world. This means more potential buyers for your Tiffany pieces and, ultimately, better prices for you!

Sell with TheRealReal


3. WP Diamonds


WP Diamonds

Selling with WP Diamonds is super easy and hassle-free. All you have to do is fill out a quick form on their website with some basic information about your jewelry. Then, they’ll give you an initial offer based on market value and demand.

They have a team of expert appraisers who will carefully evaluate your piece of Tiffany jewelry in person once it’s been shipped to them. This means that you can trust that their offer is fair and accurate.

Unlike other online buyers who may only be interested in certain types of jewelry or brands, WPDiamonds buys all types of diamond and luxury jewelry from various high-end brands including Tiffany & Co., Cartier, Van Cleef & Arpels, and more.

No matter what type of Tiffany jewelry you have - whether it’s a necklace, bracelet, or ring - they will consider buying it from you.

Sell with WPDiamonds


4. Cash for Gold USA


Cash for Gold USA

Looking for quick cash for your Tiffany jewelry? Look no further than Cash for Gold USA!

With their unrivaled reputation and expertise in the industry, they are the go-to destination for selling gold Tiffany jewelry and getting cash fast.

Their streamlined process ensures a hassle-free experience, offering competitive prices and immediate payment options. Trustworthy and reliable, Cash for Gold USA is the ultimate choice for turning your Tiffany treasures into instant cash.

Don’t wait another moment – unlock the value of your jewelry today!

Sell with Cash for Gold USA


5. Circa Jewels


Circa Jewels

When it comes to selling Tiffany jewelry specifically, Circa is a top choice because they have a team of experts who are well-versed in the brand’s history and value. They’ll be able to accurately assess the worth of your piece and offer you a fair price for it.

Another great thing about selling through CircaJewels is their simple process. You can get started by filling out an online form with details about your jewelry or just send them a photo.

From there, they’ll provide you with an initial quote within 24 hours - no need to wait around wondering how much your jewelry might be worth!

Finally, if you choose to accept their offer (which we think will be very competitive), CircaJewels will handle everything from shipping and insurance to payment processing. It’s truly hassle-free!

Sell with Circa


6. eBay



Sometimes it can be tough to find the right buyer for high-end items like Tiffany jewelry. But on eBay, there are tons of people who love buying and collecting all kinds of unique pieces.

Plus, selling on eBay is really easy – all you need to do is set up an account and list your item with some photos and a description.

One thing that’s especially nice about selling on eBay is that you get to set your own price. You can start with a higher price point if you think your piece is particularly valuable or rare, but then lower it over time if nobody bites.

And since so many people use eBay every day, chances are good that someone will eventually see your listing and want to buy from you.

So if you’re looking for an alternative way to sell your Tiffany jewelry online – one that’s easy, flexible, and potentially very lucrative – why not give eBay a try? Who knows what kind of amazing buyers might be out there waiting just for YOU!


7. TrueFacet



TrueFacet is an online marketplace that lets people buy and sell pre-owned luxury jewelry, including pieces from Tiffany & Co.

TrueFacet specializes in high-end items like diamonds and designer watches - so if you have some fancy Tiffany bling to sell, it’s probably your best bet.

Another big advantage is safety: when you list an item on TrueFacet, they authenticate it first to make sure it’s legit before posting online.

Plus, they handle all the shipping logistics themselves (including insurance!), which takes the hassle out of selling something valuable remotely.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Tiffany jewelry?

Founded in 1837 by Charles Lewis Tiffany, the company is known for its elegant and timeless designs.

Tiffany & Co. offers a wide range of jewelry items, including rings, necklaces, bracelets, and earrings. Their iconic pieces are often made from precious metals like gold, silver, and platinum, and featuring beautiful gemstones like diamonds, sapphires, and more.

The brand is famous for its iconic blue boxes and has become a symbol of style, sophistication, and romance.

How can I determine the value of my Tiffany jewelry before selling it?

To figure out how much your Tiffany jewelry is worth, you first need to know what kind of jewelry it is. For example, Tiffany engagement rings could be worth a lot! A Tiffany ring with a big diamond might be worth more than one with a smaller diamond. You can take your jewelry to a professional who knows about diamonds and Tiffany jewelry.

They can tell you how much it’s worth. If you’re thinking about selling Tiffany jewelry online, do some research to see how much similar items are selling for. That way, you’ll have a good idea of what your jewelry could sell for.

What factors affect the price of Tiffany jewelry in the resale market?

When you want to sell Tiffany jewelry, several things can change its price. The condition of your jewelry is a big one. If your Tiffany engagement ring or diamond Tiffany jewelry is well-cared for, it could sell for more! The Tiffany blue box that comes with the jewelry can also add value.

People love that box! Old Tiffany jewelry, also called antique tiffany jewelry, can be worth a lot too. Selling Tiffany jewelry online can help you find someone who really wants it and might pay a good price. Remember, Tiffany jewelry is known for its quality, which can make it worth more!

Is it better to sell Tiffany jewelry online or in a physical store?


If you have Tiffany jewelry like diamond jewelry or Tiffany rings, you might wonder where to sell them. Both online and physical stores can be good choices. Selling Tiffany engagement rings online can often get you a better price, according to a website I found.

Online, you can reach professional jewelry buyers from all over. But, a local store can also be a good option because you can talk to the buyer in person. No matter where you choose to sell, remember that your Tiffany jewelry worth can depend on its condition and age.


Bottom Line


Woman wearing gold necklace

Before selling your Tiffany jewelry online, it’s important to consider a few things. Start by learning about your jewelry, such as its name, design, and materials, so you can describe it well. Check similar Tiffany items online to help you set a fair price.

Pick a trusted website like Worthy or a site just for selling fine jewelry, and be sure to read their rules and fees.

Take bright, clear photos that show off all the details and special features of your jewelry. Always be honest in your description, including any wear or damage, as buyers will appreciate your honesty.

Finally, when it’s time to ship your jewelry, pack it safely in a sturdy box to protect it during shipping. And don’t forget to get jewelry insurance, in case anything happens during the shipping process.

By following these steps, you’ll be ready to sell your Tiffany jewelry online and make someone else happy with your beautiful piece.

Better Relationships in Just 3 Minutes a Day

This newsletter is not just good - it delivers the best relationship advice to your inbox every morning Join thousands of subscribers discovering how to stop chasing emotionally unavailable people and start attracting true love.

Don't miss the chance to add your name to the list before the next edition goes live. If you want to take advantage of this opportunity, simply click the below to access our secure sign-up page.

Try the Newsletter
About the Author:
Ryan Hart

Ryan Hart is a certified relationship coach and writer. His mission is to help make connections between people better, stronger, more meaningful, and longer lasting using technology.

Want to connect with Ryan? Click here to get his FREE daily dating advice newsletter

Better Relationships in Just 3 Minutes a Day

The best relationship advice — in your inbox — every morning.

Join 2,000+ subscribers