Blue Nile vs Brilliant Earth

by Ryan Hart | Updated on January 6, 2024 | Post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

When it comes to buying an engagement ring, two online jewelers that are often compared are Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth. Both companies have a reputation for selling high-quality diamonds, but they differ in their approach to sourcing and pricing. If you’re in the market for an engagement ring, it’s important to understand the differences between these two companies so you can make an informed decision.

Blue Nile is one of the largest online jewelers in the world, known for offering a wide selection of diamonds at competitive prices. The company was founded in 1999 and has since become a go-to destination for couples looking to buy an engagement ring online. Blue Nile sources its diamonds from reputable suppliers and offers a range of customization options, including the ability to design your own engagement ring.

On the other hand, Brilliant Earth is a newer player in the online jewelry space, founded in 2005. The company has made a name for itself by focusing on ethically sourced diamonds and other gemstones. Brilliant Earth offers a range of engagement rings, wedding bands, and other jewelry, all made with conflict-free diamonds and recycled precious metals. If you’re someone who is concerned about the environmental and ethical impact of your purchase, Brilliant Earth may be the right choice for you.

Blue Nile vs Brilliant Earth: Comparison

When it comes to buying engagement rings, Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth are two of the most popular online retailers. Both companies offer a wide selection of high-quality diamonds, ring settings, and fine jewelry. However, there are some differences between the two that you should consider before making your purchase.

Selection and Quality

Both Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth offer an extensive selection of diamonds and gemstones. Blue Nile has an inventory of over 150,000 diamonds, while Brilliant Earth has a more curated selection of conflict-free diamonds and lab-created diamonds. Both companies offer certified diamonds with detailed information on the 4Cs (cut, color, clarity, and carat weight).

When it comes to ring settings, Blue Nile offers a wide variety of styles and metals, including platinum, yellow gold, white gold, and rose gold. Brilliant Earth specializes in ethically sourced metals and offers a selection of unique vintage and antique ring settings.

Pricing and Value

Both Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth offer competitive pricing for their diamonds and ring settings. Blue Nile is known for offering lower prices than traditional brick-and-mortar jewelry stores, while Brilliant Earth focuses on ethical sourcing and sustainability in its pricing.

Both companies offer a price match guarantee and free shipping on most orders. Blue Nile also offers a diamond upgrade program, allowing customers to trade in their diamond for a larger one and only pay the difference in price.

Customer Service and Returns

Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth both have excellent customer service and return policies. Blue Nile offers a 30-day return policy with a full refund, while Brilliant Earth offers a 60-day return policy with a full refund or exchange. Both companies offer free returns and resizing for their rings.

Blue Nile has 24/7 phone and chat support, while Brilliant Earth offers support from 7 AM to 7 PM PT. Both companies have showrooms where customers can view their products in person (Blue Nile has showrooms in several locations across the US, while Brilliant Earth has showrooms in San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Boston).

Ethics and Sustainability

Both Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth offer conflict-free diamonds and ethically sourced metals. Blue Nile sources its diamonds from reputable suppliers who adhere to the Kimberley Process, while Brilliant Earth goes a step further and tracks its diamonds from their origin to ensure they are conflict-free.

Brilliant Earth also offers lab-created diamonds, which are a more sustainable and ethical alternative to natural diamonds. Both companies are committed to fair wages and ethical manufacturing practices.

Pros and Cons

In summary, Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth are both excellent choices for buying engagement rings and fine jewelry online. Blue Nile offers a larger selection of diamonds and ring settings at a lower price point, while Brilliant Earth specializes in ethically sourced metals and unique vintage ring settings.

Both companies offer excellent customer service and return policies and are committed to ethical sourcing and sustainability. Ultimately, the choice between the two comes down to personal preference and what is most important to you in your purchase.

Blue Nile

When it comes to buying jewelry online, Blue Nile is one of the most recognized names in the industry. They have been in business since 1999 and have a reputation for providing high-quality diamonds and jewelry at competitive prices. In this section, we’ll take a closer look at what Blue Nile has to offer and how they stack up against their competitor, Brilliant Earth.

Selection and Quality

Blue Nile offers a wide selection of diamonds and jewelry, including engagement rings, wedding bands, and fine jewelry. They have an extensive inventory of natural diamonds in various shapes, sizes, and colors. Their diamonds are certified by reputable third-party grading labs, such as GIA and AGS, which ensures the quality and authenticity of the diamonds.

Pricing and Value

Blue Nile is known for offering competitive prices on their diamonds and jewelry. They have a price match guarantee, which means that if you find a comparable diamond or piece of jewelry at a lower price, they will match it.

Customer Service and Returns

Blue Nile has a reputation for providing excellent customer service. They offer 24/7 customer support via phone, email, and live chat. They also have a 30-day return policy, which gives you the peace of mind to know that you can return an item if you’re not satisfied with it.

Conflict-Free Diamonds

Blue Nile is committed to selling conflict-free diamonds. They only source diamonds from reputable suppliers who adhere to the Kimberley Process, which is an international certification scheme that regulates the trade of rough diamonds to prevent the sale of diamonds that finance armed conflict.

Lab-Created Diamonds

In addition to natural diamonds, Blue Nile also offers lab-created diamonds. These diamonds are created in a laboratory using advanced technology that replicates the natural diamond-growing process. Lab-created diamonds are a more affordable and ethical alternative to natural diamonds, and they are virtually identical in appearance and quality.

Overall, Blue Nile is a reputable and reliable online jeweler that offers a wide selection of diamonds and jewelry at competitive prices. Their commitment to quality, customer service, and ethical sourcing practices make them a top choice for anyone in the market for fine jewelry.

Brilliant Earth

When it comes to selecting an engagement ring or other jewelry, Brilliant Earth is a top contender. Here’s what you need to know about their selection, quality, pricing, customer service, and ethical standards.

Selection and Quality

Brilliant Earth offers a wide variety of engagement rings, wedding bands, and other jewelry options. They specialize in ethically sourced diamonds and gemstones, as well as lab-created diamonds. Their selection includes classic and modern styles, so you’re sure to find something that suits your taste.

Brilliant Earth also prides itself on the quality of its jewelry. They use only the highest quality materials, and their diamonds are certified by reputable organizations like the Gemological Institute of America (GIA).

Pricing and Value

Brilliant Earth’s pricing is generally higher than that of some other online jewelers, but this is due to their commitment to ethical and sustainable sourcing practices. They also offer financing options to make their jewelry more accessible.

In terms of value, Brilliant Earth’s commitment to ethical sourcing and high-quality materials means that its jewelry is a worthwhile investment.

Customer Service and Returns

Brilliant Earth has a reputation for excellent customer service. They offer free shipping and returns within 30 days of purchase. They also have a lifetime warranty on their jewelry, so you can feel confident in your purchase.

Conflict-Free Diamonds

Brilliant Earth is committed to sourcing conflict-free diamonds. They only work with suppliers who adhere to their strict standards for ethical sourcing. They also offer lab-created diamonds as an alternative to mined diamonds.

Ethical Sourcing and Human Rights

In addition to conflict-free diamonds, Brilliant Earth is committed to ethical sourcing and human rights. They work with suppliers who meet their standards for fair labor practices and environmental sustainability. They also donate 5% of their profits to communities impacted by the jewelry industry.

Overall, Brilliant Earth is an excellent option for those looking for ethically sourced and high-quality jewelry. While their prices may be higher than those of some other online jewelers, their commitment to sustainability and human rights makes them a worthwhile investment.

Comparison

When it comes to buying engagement rings or fine jewelry online, two of the most popular options are Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth. Both retailers offer a wide selection of high-quality diamonds, gemstones, and settings, but there are some differences between them that you should be aware of before making a purchase.

Selection and Quality

Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth both offer a large selection of loose diamonds and ring settings, but Blue Nile has a more extensive inventory of diamonds and gemstones than Brilliant Earth. However, Brilliant Earth has a more curated selection of ethically sourced diamonds and gemstones, including lab-created diamonds and colored diamonds. Both retailers offer GIA and AGS-certified diamonds, but Brilliant Earth also offers its own certification process called Beyond Conflict Free.

When it comes to the quality of their diamonds, both Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth offer high-quality stones with excellent cut, color, and clarity grades. However, Brilliant Earth places a stronger emphasis on diamond origin and ethical sourcing than Blue Nile.

Pricing and Value

In terms of pricing, Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth are both competitive with each other and other online retailers in the jewelry industry. However, Blue Nile generally offers slightly lower prices than Brilliant Earth for similar-quality diamonds and settings. Both retailers offer a price match guarantee, but Blue Nile’s policy is more generous and includes a 100% refund.

When it comes to value, both Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth offer high-quality diamonds and settings at fair prices. However, Brilliant Earth’s emphasis on ethical sourcing and sustainability may be more valuable to some customers than Blue Nile’s more enormous inventory and lower prices.

Customer Service and Returns

Both Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth offer excellent customer service with knowledgeable and helpful representatives. However, Blue Nile has a broader range of customer service options, including 24/7 phone and chat support and a diamond upgrade program. Brilliant Earth’s customer service is available during business hours only and does not offer a diamond buyback program.

Both retailers offer free shipping and returns, but Blue Nile’s return policy is more generous, with a 30-day full refund policy. Brilliant Earth’s return policy is also 30 days, but they do not offer a full refund for custom or engraved items.

Conflict-Free Diamonds

Both Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth offer conflict-free diamonds that are responsibly sourced through the diamond mining supply chain. However, Brilliant Earth strongly emphasizes ethical sourcing and sustainability, including its Beyond Conflict Free certification process and its commitment to fair wages and working conditions for miners.

Lab-Created Diamonds

Both Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth offer lab-created diamonds as a more sustainable and affordable alternative to natural diamonds. However, Brilliant Earth has a larger selection of lab-created diamonds and places a stronger emphasis on their sustainability and ethical sourcing.

Ethical Sourcing and Human Rights

Both Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth are committed to ethical sourcing and human rights in the diamond industry. However, Brilliant Earth places a stronger emphasis on these issues and has a more transparent supply chain. They also donate 5% of their profits to help communities affected by the diamond industry.

Overall, both Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth are excellent options for buying high-quality diamonds and fine jewelry online. Your choice will depend on your priorities and values, whether it’s a larger selection and lower prices or a more curated selection and a stronger commitment to ethical sourcing and sustainability.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the differences between Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth?

Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth are two of the most prominent online jewelry retailers. While both offer a wide selection of high-quality diamonds, there are some key differences between the two. Blue Nile has a larger inventory and offers more customization options, while Brilliant Earth focuses on ethically sourced diamonds and offers unique, vintage-inspired designs.

How does the quality of Blue Nile diamonds compare to those from Brilliant Earth?

Both Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth offer high-quality diamonds that are certified by reputable grading labs. However, Brilliant Earth places a stronger emphasis on ethical sourcing and offers a range of beyond conflict-free diamonds, while Blue Nile offers a wider selection of diamonds at varying price points.

What is the price range for engagement rings at Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth?

The price range for engagement rings at Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth varies depending on the size, quality, and type of diamond, as well as the setting and metal type. Generally, Blue Nile offers more affordable options, with engagement rings starting at around $500, while Brilliant Earth’s prices tend to be higher, with engagement rings starting at around $1,000.

Are there any unique features or offerings that set Blue Nile apart from Brilliant Earth?

Blue Nile offers a Build Your Own Ring feature that allows you to customize your engagement ring by choosing the diamond, setting, and metal type. They also offer a Diamond Price Match Guarantee, which ensures that you are getting the best price for your diamond. Brilliant Earth, on the other hand, offers a wide selection of ethically sourced diamonds and unique, vintage-inspired designs.

What do customers generally say about their experiences with Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth?

Customers generally report positive experiences with both Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth, citing the quality of the diamonds and the ease of the online shopping experience. Some customers have reported issues with shipping or customer service, but these complaints are relatively rare.

How does Brilliant Earth compare to other competitors like James Allen and Leibish & Co?

Brilliant Earth stands out from competitors like James Allen and Leibish & Co. due to their strong emphasis on ethical sourcing and their unique, vintage-inspired designs. James Allen offers a similar Build Your Own Ring feature as Blue Nile, while Leibish & Co specializes in fancy colored diamonds.

Better Relationships in Just 4 Minutes a Day

This newsletter is not just good - it delivers the best relationship advice to your inbox every week. Join thousands of subscribers discovering how to find love and improve their relationships with ease.

Don't miss the chance to add your name to the list before the next edition goes live. If you want to take advantage of this opportunity, simply click the below to access our secure sign-up page.

Sign Up Today
About the Author:
Ryan Hart

Ryan Hart is a certified relationship coach and writer. His mission is to help make connections between people better, stronger, more meaningful, and longer lasting using technology.

Want to connect with Ryan? Click here to join his FREE weekly newsletter

Better Relationships in Just 4 Minutes a Week

The best relationship advice — in your inbox — every Monday.

Join 1,000+ subscribers